LOVE THAT BOB a.k.a. THE BOB CUMMINGS SHOW: "Bob Frees Schultzy for Romance" (1958 NBC-TV/Laurel-McCadden Productions) Original Air Date: June 10, 1958. Starring Bob Cummings as Bob Collins, Rosemary deCamp as Margaret MacDonald, Ann B. Davis as Charmaine "Schultzy" Schultz, Rose Marie as Martha, Lisa Gaye as Collette DuBois. Written by Paul Henning and Dick Wesson. Directed by Bob Cummings.
Series overview for LOVE THAT BOB a.k.a. THE BOB CUMMINGS SHOW at this link
The latest pending marriage around the office building raises eyebrows: former dental assistant Tilly Wessel got a man within days of changing jobs--working in a missle factory. Schultzy is still shooting for the moon with "the boss" but Martha points out the better odds that Tilly (unseen, but deemed less attractive than Charmaine by all) received with her new employment: men outnumber women at the factory 5000 to 1.
"When your hair has turned to silver, men only want your gold!"
Visions of waiting until her golden years has Schultzy mulling Martha's advice, particularly after model Collette gets the kisses while Schultzy gets to paint the sets. Meeting men while working for Bob Collins Photography seems highly unlikely, and Margaret joins the chorus to free the long-pining secretary to pursue greener pastures at the factory with Tilly's position opening there.
"I've seen better creatures through a glass bottom boat!"
The penultimate episode from an excellent fourth season, Bob Frees Schultzy for Romance finds the supporters of Team Schultzy waving the white flag on Project Bob and encouraging her to go where the numbers are. Bob remains the ultimate challenge, though, and both Charmaine and Collette remain fiercely determined to get the Shutterbug Hefner to settle down. Martha certainly seems interested in replacing Schultzy should she flee, though!
"For the last time, for the very last time, Schultzy's getting married has absolutely nothing to do with me!"
Bob's disinclination to accept Martha's "offer" is be the his new Girl Friday is understandable. Schultzy might throw an envious aside Collette's way now and then, but Martha seems downright mean spirited in her jealousy. First she paints the model's open hand after she's in costume for the shoot, then steals her clothes to keep the Mademoiselle away from lunch at the factory. Can you picture anyone but Charmaine Schultz willfully taking a backseat (and the occasional male role in a photo session) to the cover girls? If you can, Martha Randolph ain't on the list of candidates from the evidence we're given.
"You were so right, kid, you have nothing on for lunch!"
Speaking of, she takes off with Bob's steak! This marks Rose Marie's return after Bob Retrenches, but the first as her permanent recurring character Martha Randolph. Martha's peppy pettiness creates an impression that would bring her back into the fold eight times for the final season. She takes on some of Schultzy's stinkerish prior characteristics, elevating the aide in our eyes. Immediately an Emmy worthy sidekick to Davis, Marie would garner three Emmy nominations in her own signature role in THE DICK VAN DYKE SHOW the following decade.
Davis won her first Emmy this season for her third nomination, and wins the audience over even when she's blocking our hero. Schultzy is certainly playing fair compared to Martha, even refusing to go to the missile factory unless Collette is invited too. Schultzy always exudes confidence that the quality underneath the surface will eventually win out--though as a dream sequence hints, it may take fifty or sixty years. While she will block on occasion, Charmaine commendably refuses to settle for other prospective beaus (Bob Batches It) and more often that not takes on the perceived competition without much skullduggery. Ann B. Davis repeated as Best Supporting Actress winner in 1958-59, impressively helping to carry lesser material (we are 130 episodes in at this point) during LOVE THAT BOB's slow decline from its peak in its final bow.
"We will go to my place for lunch and I will show you how I make Eggs Benedict."
Lisa Gaye's Collette du Bois was our second most frequently seen model behind Joi Lansing's Shirley Swanson, more modest but always holding her own against the buxom blonde. She always seems the most genuinely interested in marrying Bobby boy, willing to cook at least but implying she'd like some help with the housework that Schutzy doesn't bat an eye at. She's the star attraction in front of Collins' camera but the straight woman for Bob, Charmaine and Martha in front of director Cummings'. Still she manages to wring the chuckles out of that capacity with her trained responses to every photographer direction. And yes, Bob should have chosen Collette's lunch invite that over the non nourishing nagging he got at home in lieu of a midday meal.
![]() |
| yeah, Bob, shoulda been a no brainer, young man... |
A winning new recurring character, my personal favorite recurring model and a nicely paced full day at Collins Photography. What's not to like? Our trio of 1957-58 writers is down to a duo, with Henning and Wesson sans Shirley Gordon in a preview of what was to come for the duration of 1958-59. Her presence would be missed when it came to writing dialogue for the ladies, and while it doesn't detract much here, to my ear she might have refined a patchy line or two. During it's second through fourth season prime years, LOVE THAT BOB always had at least three and sometimes four credited writers--this is the of the very first since the 1955 premiere set to have the team pared down to a duo (then, it was Henning and Bill Manhoff) and the reduction of minds and womanly input would become noticeable in future installments.
While not technically a two parter as the season ended with Bob's Forgotten Fiancee the following week, the fifth season would open with a sequel, Bob and Schulzty Reunite, in which the effervescent assistant decides to explore that missile factory job.
DID BOB SCORE?
Not this time; he had Collette secured for the evening (and much more if he wanted) but his effort to drive Schultzy away for his own good was too convincing, with Miss Du Bois startled by his "cruelty". Since Lisa Gaye returned several times in the fifth and final season we can assume he made amends later. Martha made an offer to fill in for Collette as well as the assistant job which was, of course, rebuffed. Decisively.
WHO WAS BLOCKING?
This time, 'Bobby' blocked himself as noted above. To be fair, he was under enormous pressure from Martha and especially Margaret prior to his ill-advised "act" at the studio, with starvation being added to the usual pestering. So while he unwittingly did himself in for the evening, the M and M's blocked his lunch.
SOMETHING WE VERY RARELY SEE:
Despite sponsorship by Winston, off screen Cummings was anti smoking and told anyone who would listen that cigarettes would destroy their health, nearly a decade ahead of the Surgeon General's 1964 report. For that reason you didn't see him lighting up for the commercials on camera, but I've now found two episodes in which you see him actually take a drag (see photo above). Bob in Orbit is the other.
BOTTOM LINE:
A terrific 1957-58 season remains dependable in its home stretch. Ultimately, status quo is still king after all that pestering from Margaret and Martha. Rose Marie makes a hilarious case for increased involvement in future episodes (which she was given) and Lisa Gaye scores solidly on the laugh meter with her professionalism in the face of heartbreak. Yet another good time to be had at Collins Photography. Though I do think some lines seem to be missing Shirley Gordon's crucial input the cast and director make this vehicle sail smoothly. (*** out of four)
Want to see Bob Frees Schultzy for Romance for yourself? It is available for viewing with original network commercials (for Winston and Vaseline) intact on YouTube courtesy Moviecraft Inc. See below!














No comments:
Post a Comment